The ACA is Dead. It’s Time to Admit Phone Calls Aren’t Enough.
This week Donald Trump finally carried out his threat to aggressively sabotage the Affordable Care Act. This action should come as no surprise. What should come as a surprise, though, is that the left, the Democratic Party and #TheResistance had absolutely no strategy to counter this move. Nothing.
They were happy to pretend that their phone calls and pity tweets saved the ACA. They were happy to pretend that the game was over and there was nothing left to do. But they did not strategically preparedto counter Trump’s next move and they did absolutely nothing to try to stop it.
Earlier this week, SIIP published an op-ed stating:
“You can’t blame the pussy grabbing, rape promoting, wife assaulting (“allegedly”), child molesting (“allegedly”), woman bashing piece of shit named Donald Trump and his turdlings in the Republican Party for being what they are and doing what they do.
Of course they are going to target women.
Of course they are going to try to steal a Supreme Court Seat and eventually overturn Roe v. Wade.
Of course they are going to try to defund our social safety nets.
Of course they are going to try to take our healthcare.
Of course they are going to try to pass abortion restrictions.
And, of course they are going to try to deny us access to birth control….
You can’t blame Steph Curry for making 3 pointers. You can’t blame Le’Veon Bell for driving into the end zone. And you can’t blame Trump and the GOP for taking Women’s Rights. They only people you can blame are the defenders that fail to stop them.
The real people to blame for the loss of our rights, our healthcare and our birth control are the people that are trained and paid to stop the Republican Party and the activists that they pimp.”
For months now, the left has held a mass delusion that phone calls would be enough to stop a criminal network of white supremacists and traitors hellbent on destroying the nation from advancing their agenda. As if the Civil War, WWII, the Civil Rights Movement, police brutality, poverty, homelessness, etc…could have all just been called away with those delicate middle-class fingers.
Fingers so delicate and magical and unworn from privilege that they can make the GOP and white supremacy go away with less than 5 minutes of effort. Magical enough to produce such incredible results that — even though never in the history of social struggle has justice ever been a mere phone call away — they could ensure victory in every battle from tax reform to saving the Affordable Care Act.
Soft, magical, precious little fingers. Full of fucking bullshit.
This unicorn-worthy and insultingly privileged delusion of how social reform works just cost me, my kids, and tens of millions of other people our healthcare. People are going to die en masse not only because the GOP launched an assault, but when the time came for the left to stand up and fight — they chose to do nothing. They chose to play make-believe. They chose to twiddle their fingers.
Correction.
Indivisible and the Democrats chose something worse than nothing. They convinced those that wanted to fight back that they didn’t need to engage in the actions necessary to stop the GOP. They stopped the left from fighting back and locked them into a pattern of phone calls and shame tweets. They convinced the resistance to neutralize itself. And in doing so, they handed a victory over to the GOP.
The Democrats and the Indivisible Guide handed our lives over to the Republican Party so that they could keep those delicate fingers well manicured and soft.
And they can both fuck themselves for that.
If we learn anything from the death of the Affordable Healthcare Act, it needs to be that we need to work harder, do better, and stop making excuses to engage in strategies that take zero effort and have proven time and time again to fail. That’s not how we win. It’s never how any battle for rights and lives has ever been won. And it’s not how any battle against Trump and the GOP will be won now.
And snarkily some of you velvet gloved cosplay activists are saying, “Well, what’s the solution then?” SIIP publishes solutions and action items almost weekly. Don’t worry, there’s nothing but alternatives to doing practically nothing. But none of them will matter unless you admit what you are doing right now doesn’t work. So sink into that for a bit. Right now.
You got your asses handed to you by the GOP. Millions of live are now at risk. Many will die. And it’s not just because the Republican Party is engaging in a genocidal attack against the nation; it’s because the left refuses to do what it takes to stop them.
So if you feel like shit right now because your phone calls didn’t work — good. That’s fantastic. You deserve to feel like shit right now. Mourn that loss. Then use those precious little fingers to pick your ass back up and dedicate yourself to working harder, doing better and never letting this happen again.
Admit calling campaigns are lazy, they are not appropriate to counter the threat we are up against, and they haven’t worked once. Not fucking once. Read the specific reasons why this strategy is and will always be a complete failure. Take it in. Resolve to do better. Burn your indivisible guide. And start fighting back with every last muscle, bone and cell in your body — not just the tip of your finger.
Below is a piece SIIP published over a month ago. It will help you understand in detail why the Indivisible Guide does not, cannot, and will not work. At the end of the article is a link to a number of strategic solutions you and your Representatives can engage in to start protecting our communities and pushing back the GOP. Take them. Run with them. And get to work.
5 Reasons to Burn Your Indivisible Guide
This article will cover the following:
5. The Indivisible Guide was written by people WITH power, not people that fight it.
4. The stated goal of the Indivisible Guide is to shape the left in the image of Tea Party.
3. Even in the context of replicating the Tea Party, they Indivisible Guide does a really shitty job of it.
2. The Indivisible Guide is designed to succeed in a context that we just don’t exist in.
1. The Indivisible Guide isn’t designed to work. It hasn’t worked. It doesn’t work. And It’s not going to work.
Here we go…
5. The Indivisible Guide was written by people WITH power, not people that fight it.
As described in the Indivisible Guide, “The authors of this guide are former congressional staffers who witnessed the rise of the Tea Party.”
Let’s pause there.
Congressional staffers.
Not trained, qualified strategists. Not experts from communities that are career-professionals in confronting abuses of authority. Not people that have ever spent a day in their lives confronting power, especially the advances of federalized white power, from a position of severe disadvantage.
Congressional staffers. Oh, and witnesses.
They watched. They didn’t use their positions of authority to confront the Tea Party effectively under a Democratic president; however, they believe they have the key to confronting the GOP from a minority position as they illegitimately occupy all 3 branches of government, the federal government is being dismantled, our global alliances have been destroyed — and tens of millions of men, women and children’s lives are actively at stake. Including mine and my children.
Because they sat in a tower and watched.
It makes as much sense to ask them how to perform an appendectomy on your child or how to fly a fully loaded passenger plane as it does to ask them to tell you how to confront the GOP. The authors of the Indivisible Guide are strategists as much as they are surgeons or pilots. And their ineptitude puts lives in immediate danger.
4. The stated goal of the Indivisible Guide is to shape the left in the image of Tea Party.
As the Indivisible Guide explains:
“We saw these activists take on a popular president with a mandate for change and a supermajority in Congress. We saw them organize locally and convince their own MoCs [Members of Congress] to reject President Obama’s agenda. Their ideas were wrong, cruel, and tinged with racism — and they won….To this end, the following chapters offer a step-by-step guide for individuals, groups, and organizations looking to replicate the Tea Party’s success in getting Congress to listen to a small, vocal, dedicated group of constituents.”
This goal makes absolutely no sense whatsoever. None.
The left does not share the same goals, constituencies, histories, opportunities, challenges, resources or positions of influence or political context as the right. There is no strategic value in ignoring the already organized underclass and minority grassroots in order to focus on creating an ethnically cleansed network of organizers whose goal is to be more like the Tea Party — not to stop Donald Trump and the GOP.
Even without a strategic analysis, though, it should absolutely go without saying that those fighting white supremacy — especially people of color, people living with disabilities, poor folks, members of the LGBTQ community and non-Christians — should not seek to replicate it. Ever.
What the left can and should do, though, is analyze losses, victories, and stalemates from particular political positions in very specific contexts and use that information to adopt strategies that suit the current context, resources, networks, actors, and communities in play.
The left and right are operating on the same battlefields, but we do not operate under similar circumstances. The left needs to have a very clearly understand of the offensive and defensive maneuvers being used by the right, how they have been countered and failed to be countered historically, and what cautions need to be taken to adapt those strategies to the current context. Without this basic level of understanding, an effective counterstrategy cannot be designed.
But I’ve seen people put more thought into their fantasy football teams than they do into their resistance. The authors of the Indivisible Guide are among them.
As the Indivisible Guide sees it, the left just needs to shapeshift into the alt-right, beat it at its own game and claim its rightful victory — even though it doesn’t know what that game is, how to play, where the stadium is located or what team they are even on. Rather than design an accurate strategy to confront the GOP, the authors of the Indivisible Guide suggest that the left plays the shadow game — with white supremacists.
This approach is strategically incorrect. And beyond creepy.
3. Even in the context of replicating the Tea Party, they Indivisible Guide does a really shitty job of it.
As the Indivisible Guide inexplicably proclaims, or rather misinforms:
“The Tea Party’s success came down to two critical strategic elements:
1. THEY WERE LOCALLY FOCUSED.
2. THEY WERE ALMOST PURELY DEFENSIVE.
- Groups focused on defense, not policy development. In response to the 2008 bank bailouts and President Obama’s election, groups began forming to discuss their anger and what could be done. They eventually realized that the locally based discussion groups themselves could be a powerful tool.
- Groups rejected concessions to Democrats and targeted weak Republicans. Tea Partiers viewed concessions to Democrats as betrayal. This limited their ability to negotiate, but they didn’t care. Instead they focused on scaring congressional Democrats and keeping Republicans honest. As a result, few Republicans spoke against the Tea Party for fear of attracting blowback.
- Groups focused on local congressional representation. Tea Partiers primarily applied this defensive strategy by pressuring their own local MoCs. This meant demanding that their Representatives and Senators be their voice of opposition on Capitol Hill. At a tactical level, the Tea Party had several replicable practices, including:
- Showing up to the MoC’s town hall meetings and demanding answers
- Showing up to the MoC’s office and demanding a meeting
- Coordinating blanket calling of congressional offices at key moments”
This couldn’t be a more deceptive description. As reported by SIIP shortly after the election:
The alt-right political network, though, had been preparing for the 2016 election since long before Bannon joined the team. The Heritage Foundation, the American Enterprise Institute and Citizen’s United all continued to gather influence in the political field. Charles and David Koch’s organization Citizens for a Sound Economy split into two groups in 2004. One group, the Americans for Prosperity, would become the protest and media arm of the alt-right’s political movement. The other arm, Freedomworks, would serve as the ground team for state and local elections and a political lifeline for the Tea Party.
The Koch Brothers teamed up again with Bert Rein and American Enterprise Institute’s Ed Blum to push their alt-right agenda in the courts through the Project on Fair Representation (founded in 2005). The mission of this organization is to “is to facilitate pro bono legal representation to political subdivisions and individuals that wish to challenge government distinctions and preferences made on the basis of race and ethnicity.” Their primary target was the Voting Rights Act of 1965. Specifically, the Project on Fair Representation sought to remove the provision that required certain jurisdictions to gain approval of the federal government before making changes in their voting policies. The removal of this restriction would allow states to make adjustments to their voting policies that directly benefitted the Republican party and the alt-right agenda.
In 2011, the Charles and David Koch founded Freedom Partners in order to funnel grant money into activist organizations and ground level political actions. In 2013, the alt-right network was successful in their efforts to gut the Voting Rights Act when they won the case of Shelby County vs Holden (2013). In related practical efforts, Citizens United and Americans for Prosperity were taken to court for accusations of voter suppression efforts in states such as Florida, Virginia, Wisconsin, North Carolina, and Michigan. Using characteristically aggressive tactics, including the strategic suppression of minority voters, the alt-right network was able to make dramatic waves in the 2010 and 2014 elections — and the Republican party was able to take control of Congress.
The Alt-right’s checklist to take control of the federal government without the use of military force was as follows:
- Infiltrate Congress — Achieved 2010
- Eliminate Funding Restrictions — Achieved 2010
- Take Control of the RNC — Achieved in 2011
- Kill Voting Protections — Achieved in 2013
- Take Control of Congress — Achieved in 2014
- Take Control of the Supreme Court — Achieved if 1) Obama administration doesn’t successfully counter efforts to delay appointment and 2) if the Republican candidate secures the Presidency
- Take Control of the Presidency — Goal:2016
By 2016, all that was left for the alt-right to achieve a full takeover of the government of the United States — without firing one shot — was gaining control of the Presidency.”
The rise of the Tea Party was the direct result of a coordinated long-term strategy that was in no way solely focused on the local level. This strategy combined local, state, and federal strategies that heavily used the courts, the GOP, strategy firms, the media and grassroots activism — among other illegal activities such as deprivation of rights and treason — in order to achieve their goals.
The goals of the far right could not be achieved with grassroots activism alone.
The rise of the Tea Party was also not solely defensive. As described above, the GOP was strategically invested in a very heavy offensive attack. This attack included the destruction of voting rights through the courts, voter ID laws, and the Interstate Crosscheck System. It included offensive attacks on minority communities and Democratic voters through the main stream media and social media. It also included an offensive strategy that promoted, and still promotes, intimidation and physical violence.
This offensive could only be ignored if you come from a position of privilege which enables you to ignore strategies that attack poor, POC and PWD communities. It can also only be ignored if you have no foundation from which to speak as an expert on confronting racism, authoritarianism or federalized white supremacy.
And so it predictably follows that the Congressional staffers turned self-proclaimed messiahs of political counterstrategy, completely ignored the GOP offensive. And, as already described, without acknowledging the opponent’s offense, there is no possible way to design a defense to counter it. Without a strong defense — especially a defense against the deprivation of minority rights — the left has no chance whatsoever of stopping the advances of Trump and the GOP.
2. The Indivisible Guide is designed to succeed in a context that we just don’t exist in.
The Indivisible Guide promotes the idea that:
“IT’S ALL ABOUT REELECTION, REELECTION, REELECTION.
To influence your own Member of Congress (MoC), you have to understand one thing: every House member runs for office every two years and every Senator runs for election every six years. Functionally speaking, MoCs are always either running for office or getting ready for their next election — a fact that shapes everything they do.
…This constant reelection pressure means that MoCs are enormously sensitive to their image in the district or state, and they will work very hard to avoid signs of public dissent or disapproval.”
Unfortunately, when you know how to rig an election, you don’t need to respond to a constituency. Between Russian intervention, voter ID laws, the Interstate Crosscheck System and violations of the ADA, the Republicans are behaving, with good reason, as if they have 2018 in the bag. And since the Democrats have done nothing to confront these issues — the GOP is right.
Rather than confront the obstacles that prevent the Democrats from winning at the polls, they continue to rely on 2 core strategies:
1. We aren’t the GOP, so people HAVE to vote for us.
2. We don’t have to engage in a political battle, we can win in the court of public opinion
Both of these strategies have cost the Democrats every single major election since 2010. Rather than confront the failures of this strategy, though, the Indivisible Guide enthusiastically adopts the and further diffuses them through their “activist” network — along with a package of resistance tactics designed more for collaboration with the GOP than confrontation.
Town halls, local public events, district office visits, coordinated calls have no history of success in political reform movements.
Unless you think our indigenous elders were wrong, and you believe our genocide could have been prevented by a town hall meeting. Or maybe if you believe the Civil War could have been prevented and slavery would have ended if more community meetings had been held. Perhaps if you believe the soldiers that fought the Nazis during World War II were really just over-reacting and millions of lives could have been saved if just a few more calls to Congress were made, then the Indivisible Guide might seem like an effective tool. Or if you really believe segregation would have ended by just having a meeting with your local representatives, then the Indivisible Guide make sense.
But if you have even the most novice understanding of struggle and reform, the suggestions provided in the Indivisible Guide are as ridiculous as the idea that the GOP will be stopped by a tactic that can be blocked with the purchase of an answering machine or a simple refusal to attend a meeting.
But then again, the authors of the Indivisible Guide admit that their goal is NOT to stop the Trump Administration or the GOP. And this brings us to our Number one reason to light the Indivisible Guide on Fire…
1. The Indivisible Guide isn’t designed to work. It hasn’t worked. It doesn’t work. And It’s not going to work.
Before we proceed, ask yourself this: When has calling Congress or attending a town hall worked to stop the Trump Administration?
The Answer?
Never.
Not once.
The Indivisible Guide’s plan to call and town hall away the Trump Train has not done one thing to stop the Trump Administration and the GOP from advancing its legislative agenda.
(Now you may be telling yourself that you saved Obamacare by calling Congress when the GOP was trying to pass the AHCA. Obamacare wasn’t saved by #Indivisible. It was stalled by the Freedom Caucus. And when it was adjusted to suit their needs, not the needs of the people, it was passed through the House. Despite phone calls and town halls. So, no, unless you think you are the Freedom Caucus, the Indivisible Guide did not stop the destruction of our national healthcare system. What it did do, though, is convince its followers that it had succeeded, prevented them from preparing for the GOP’s second attempt at passing Trumpcare through the house, and left 24million people in harm’s way with no tangible defense. This outcome is not the same as saving Obamacare. To learn more, click here.)
So let me repeat, the strategies promoted by the Indivisible Guide have not worked once. Ever.
And there is one core reason for that: The Indivisible Guide was not written to be a success. It was written to stall your resistance until the 2018 Election cycle. As the Indivisible Guide itself states:
“By adopting a defensive strategy that pressures MoCs [Members of Congress], we can achieve the following goals:
- Stall the Trump agenda by forcing them to redirect energy away from their priorities…
- Sap Representatives’ will to support or drive reactionary change. If you do this right, you will have an outsized impact. Every time your MoC signs on to a bill, takes a position, or makes a statement, a little part of his or her mind will be thinking: “How am I going to explain this to the angry constituents who keep showing up at my events and demanding answers?”
- Reaffirm the illegitimacy of the Trump agenda. The hard truth is that Trump, McConnell, and Ryan will have the votes to cause some damage. But by objecting as loudly and powerfully as possible, and by centering the voices of those who are most affected by their agenda, you can ensure that people understand exactly how bad these laws are from the very start — priming the ground for the 2018 midterms and their repeal when Democrats retake power.”
The goal is not to stop the GOP, its legislative advances, or the Trump Administration. The goal of the Indivisible Guide is to stall, shame, and scream at the GOP until they are magically voted away in 2018 — without confronting voter purging, suppression, or Russian interference.
And this strategy will never work to stop the GOP, although it’s followers falsely believe it will. This false belief prevents them from engaging in strategies that will actually achieve that goal. And in that way, the members of #Indivisible prevent strategies and counterstrategies that work from being enacted — in the name of resistance.
And that’s why the Indivisible Guide should be burned. It should be lit on fire, used as toilet paper, put at the bottom of a bird cage, bound and buried — anything except be used as a manual to stop the GOP. Which is what must be done. And time is running out.
The Strategic Institute of Intersectional Policy has been tirelessly publishing strategies that can be used by politicians and people alike to completely shut down the GOP and the Trump Administration. They are for people that are ready to fight with every cell and breath in their bodies — not just the tips of their fingers.
For more information on what the left can and should do to stop the GOP, click here.
